-->
Dear QueryShark,
Drew Nolan knew cooperation could make his life easier, but only if he betrayed everything that mattered to him. Day after day, he entered an interrogation room and faced Ceked Mirko. Day after day he sparred, verbally and mentally, with that cold, arrogant bastard. Then the interrogations got worse, then the torture began. How long could he, or his shipmates, hold out?
Drew Had visited a dozen star systems as a young officer, but nothing prepared him for the bitter reality of Kasdech. He knew the cramped confines of starships, not the mud of planets. Yet, after the Kasdech attack, that is exactly where he finds himself; locked in a frozen prison camp beside his fellow survivors.
Drew Nolan knew cooperation could make his life easier, but only if he betrayed everything that mattered to him. Day after day, he entered an interrogation room and faced Ceked Mirko. Day after day he sparred, verbally and mentally, with that cold, arrogant bastard. Then the interrogations got worse, then the torture began. How long could he, or his shipmates, hold out?
Drew Had visited a dozen star systems as a young officer, but nothing prepared him for the bitter reality of Kasdech. He knew the cramped confines of starships, not the mud of planets. Yet, after the Kasdech attack, that is exactly where he finds himself; locked in a frozen prison camp beside his fellow survivors.
At this point, we don't know anything more about the plot
than we did after the first sentence. You're giving us backstory and set up.
Get to what's at stake here!
War between Kasdech and Earth is coming, and Mirko knows it. Interrogation is his business, and he will stop at nothing to extract the information his superiors require. Drew has learned much in war, but one lesson stands above the rest: you take care of your crew. He isn’t ready for command—he is too young, too unproven—but his crew needs him, he is all they have left.
War between Kasdech and Earth is coming, and Mirko knows it. Interrogation is his business, and he will stop at nothing to extract the information his superiors require. Drew has learned much in war, but one lesson stands above the rest: you take care of your crew. He isn’t ready for command—he is too young, too unproven—but his crew needs him, he is all they have left.
This still isn't plot. What's going to happen? War? Ok.
What's at stake? What bad thing will happen to Drew if he betrays everything
that matters to him? What worse thing will happen if he doesn't?
In the camp, under Mirko’s ungentle hands, is only suffering and misery. In escape is the smallest hint of hope, the tiny chance to save this crew and bring home a warning. Even if escape’s likeliest outcome is death, some things are worth dying for.
We still don't have a sense of the plot here at all.
THE VOLGA INCIDENT is science fiction, complete at 120,000 words, and is my first novel.
Thank you for you time and consideration
There's a formula for getting the basics of your plot written down.
I copied this from my handout on effective query letters that I've posted a couple times:
3. A query letter MUST tell an
agent what the book is about
3a Who is the main character?
3b What does he want?
3c What is keeping him from getting what he wants?
3d What must he sacrifice to get what she wants?
3a Who is the main character?
3b What does he want?
3c What is keeping him from getting what he wants?
3d What must he sacrifice to get what she wants?
Example:
3a
Jack Reacher
3b
wants to see the grave of an old, almost forgotten blues musician
3c
when he is suddenly, inexplicably arrested for a murder he could not have
committed.
3d
When the guy behind the false arrest is also killed, Reacher can stay in town,
at great peril
to himself, to solve the case or he can leave shake the dust of this crazy town
off his sneakers
and get on with his wandering.
How to convey what the book is about:
3e
The main character must decide whether to: do THIS or do THAT
3f
If s/he decides to do (this), the consequences/outcome/peril s/he faces are:
3g
If s/he decides NOT to do this:
the consequences/outcome/peril s/he faces are:
Example:
3e
Katniss Everdeen must decide whether to take her younger sister's place when
she is called
to be their district's entry in the Hunger Games.
3f
If she goes in her sister's place, her family will suffer because Katniss'
hunting skills are
what keeps them from starving now;
3g
If she decides not to go, her sister will surely die in the Games.
This is not intended to show the exact wording you use in a
query, but will help you distill your plot to the essentials. You need the
essentials of Act One, not a rundown of the entire plot.
You're going backwards here.
the first query was actually more effective than this one.
That kind of thing can happen. Don't let it damage your confidence.
Just look at the original query again, and use the good parts (there were a lot) and improve the parts that need it.
Revise/resend.
Dear QueryShark:
Drew Nolan knew cooperation could make his life easier, but only if he betrayed everything that mattered to him. Day after day he entered an interrogation room and faced Ceked Mirko. Day after day he sparred, verbally and mentally, with that cold, ruthless bastard. Then the interrogations got worse, then the torture began. How long could he, or his shipmates, hold out?
This paragraph does something quite amazing: it uses my own assumptions to surprise me. The first four sentences allow me to assume that Drew Nolan is conducting the interrogation. I'm used to the good guy being the one in charge in an interrogation room (one too many crime novels!) Yes, that first line gives us a clue, but it's not until the last line that I thought "oh! Ceked Mirko is the one running the show."
This is a Really Good Thing to do in a query because it engages my interest from the get-go.
I'm keen to read on and find out what's happening here.
Drew had come to Kasdech a rising young naval officer on a simple first contact mission. Over the course of twenty-four hours he had seen his captain killed, his ship destroyed, and his few fellow survivors locked beside him in a frozen prison camp. He wasn’t ready to be in command—he was too young, too unproven—but his crew needed him, he was all they had left. Drew had learned much in war, and one lesson stood above all else: you took care of your crew.
Ok, so we get the larger picture of what's going on here.
Mirko
You've gone from what's happened before to what's going to unfold in the novel. Change from past tense to reflect that, as per the first sentence mark up.
Why Mirko is trying to "break the prisoners." They're in a prison camp, so my expectation is simply that they're being held prisoner. This interrogation and "breaking" leads me to think something more is at stake. You say "cooperation will make things easier" in paragraph one. Spelling out what this cooperation is would be a good idea.
THE VOLGA INCIDENT is military science fiction, complete at 120,000 words, and is my first novel.
I don't get much sense of the science fiction angle here other than the names, "first contact" and "his ship." I'm not suggesting you drown the query in world building at all, but some hints would be good.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
As it stands right now, I'd probably read the pages. The pages will need to drop us right smack dab in to the middle of something happening, and give us a sense of the world these people are inhabiting very soon.
Polish up, resend. You're almost there.
